The First-Year Pivot Point: Where Student Persistence is Won or Lost

PUBLISHED:

Starting college is one of the most pivotal transitions in a student’s life. It’s a pivot point — the fragile space between excitement and exhaustion, between arrival and stop-out. In TimelyCare’s recent webinar, The First-Year Pivot Point: Where Persistence Is Won or Lost, leaders from Elon University, Texas State University, and the National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience shared insights on how institutions can support students during this critical transition.

  • Belonging is one of the best predictive factors of first-year student success
  • Collaboration across campus departments is essential for the early intervention necessary to keep students enrolled
  • Normalizing struggle can reduce stigma and build resilience among college students
  • Peer support and early outreach help prevent loneliness and the risk of stopping out
  • Institutions must adapt to serve diverse student populations with flexible support options

Incoming students are eager to succeed. Nearly two-thirds describe themselves as “thrilled and optimistic” or “cautiously excited” about starting college. However, beneath that optimism lies a significant strain, as revealed in TimelyCare’s 2025 survey, New Class, New Conversations: What Incoming Freshmen Want Colleges to Know.

Source: New Class, New Conversations: What Incoming Freshmen Want Colleges to Know

The time between arriving on campus and stopping out is where meaningful connection, care, and belonging can change a student’s path entirely.

During the webinar, panelists emphasized that the challenges first-year students face are multifaceted, from finances to belonging.

Belonging and early connection

First-generation experiences

Campus-specific challenges

The discussion highlighted the critical need for comprehensive support addressing the hurdles in front of students that can keep them from meeting their academic goals.

How Are Identity and Belonging Evolving?

One audience question was asked about how the elimination of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives might affect students.

Black responded, “The verdict is still out. But we know community and belonging will always be central. We must keep creating spaces where students feel supported regardless of policy shifts.”

Lehman added, “Higher ed doesn’t exist in a vacuum. This is a chance to rethink how we build equity into the fabric of our institutions, so that every student feels they belong.”

Even as DEI initiatives are removed, the discussion during the webinar emphasized the importance of college and university campuses fostering community and belonging by integrating equity into institutional practices.

Another consistent theme from the panelists’ discussion was the importance of collaboration across departments.

Integrated communication across campus departments

Using real-time data to quickly address student issues

By being intentional with collaboration in communication and leveraging resources like real-time data, colleges and universities can remove barriers for students, ensuring a seamless and supportive campus experience.

Loneliness is one of the most pressing issues facing first-year students. Even with abundant programming, many students opt out of engagement opportunities.

Technology plus outreach

Peer-to-peer support

Building community

Texas State University’s peer-to-peer support program, “Bobcat Chats,” offers students the opportunity to meet with resident assistants in their hall twice per semester. This is just one example of how colleges and universities are taking a variety of approaches to combat loneliness and build connections among students.

Students often arrive believing their college experience should be flawless. Panelists agreed that institutions must take steps to help change that perception.

Normalize imperfection

Build confidence

By creating an environment where growth is encouraged, mistakes are viewed as learning opportunities, and resilience is celebrated, institutions can help students transition from surviving to thriving on their educational journey.

5 Evidence-Based Practices to Establish First-Year Success for College Students

Based on the panelists’ insights, consider these five evidence-based practices that your college or university can implement to boost first-year student success:

Create intentional opportunities for students to connect with peers, faculty, and mentors.

Ensure students can access what they need to stay on track, such as food, childcare, and financial resources.

Offer flexible options for support for online, adult, and first-gen students.

Use early alerts and dashboards that combine the insights of real-time data with personal outreach.

5. Normalize Struggle and Take Steps to Build Resilience

By weaving together a strong sense of community, comprehensive student support, and a growth-oriented mindset, institutions can build a campus culture where first-year students can stay engaged and minimize risk of students stopping out.

How TimelyCare Helps First-Year Students at the Pivot Point

The transition into college will always come with challenges. But with the right support, students can turn those challenges into opportunities for growth. As Lehman said, “The image of a college student is no longer a monolith. Today’s learners are diverse, and higher ed must be agile enough to meet them where they are.”

TimelyCare partners with colleges to ensure every student receives the care, connection, and community they need to thrive.

Contact us to learn how we can help your campus thrive.

FAQ

Why is the first year of college so critical?

The first year of college sets the tone for student persistence, academic success, and well-being.

How does TimelyCare support first-year students?

Through mental health care, peer support, and tools that help campuses respond early and often.

What are some signs a college student may be at risk of stopping out?

Social withdrawal, missed assignments, or a drop in engagement with campus services can all be signs that a student may be disengaging and considering leaving school.

What strategies are most effective at supporting first-year college students?

Integrated support, proactive outreach, and a campus culture that normalizes struggle can help first-year students when they have the pivot point of having arrived on campus and considering stopping out.